Every day with fifth-graders:
Conversation #13, 8:20 a.m.
Mrs. D: ...Now write your own sentences using these new vocab words.
[20 seconds later]
Student #1: Do these sentences all have to be true?
Mrs. D: No, you can make up sentences. Like Brandon's earlier sentence about space aliens -- he doesn't really think aliens are coming to Earth.
Students #1, 5, & 17 [in unison, earnestly]: But what if there really WERE space aliens coming to Earth??
Conversation #79, 9:58 a.m.
[Mrs. D is describing Black Friday, to demonstrate supply and demand.]
Mrs. D: There are so many people who want the same thing you do that they might grab it out of your hands.
Mrs. D: There are so many people who want the same thing you do that they might grab it out of your hands.
Student #1: But why can't you just grab it off the shelf and run?
Student #2: Because there's too many people in the way.
Student #3: I would just have my little kid hold it and run in between all their legs.
Student #4: No, I would...
[ka-boom! a fast-paced dialogue on Black-Friday strategies is now underway...]
Conversation #153, 11:41 a.m.
Mrs. D: I want you to describe your home. Write down at least three details - could be its location, size, color - things like that. Just short and sweet.
[20 seconds later]
Mark [hand in the air]: I have a question! Well, you see, my house is brick, but I can't figure out how to write the color.
Mrs. D: Isn't it red or orange?
Mark: No, it's not really red or orange, kind of in-between..."
Mrs. D [patiently]: Just brick is fine.
Mark: But you said to write the color.
Mrs. D: Well, red-ish then.
Mark: No, but see, it's not really just reddish either, because a long time ago my little sisters drew on it with chalk, so it has like purple and blue and green spots on some parts of it --
Mrs. D: -- Just write brick.
[9 more minutes till the lunch bell...]
[9 more minutes till the lunch bell...]
---------------------------------------------------------
I should clarify:
We like our students -- a great deal, actually. Mrs. D. doesn't really count down the minutes till lunch.
We are just impressed with their indefatigable ability to generate questions about any thing under the sun...